Siesta Key FL Recently Sold Homes

Siesta Key Recently Sold Homes

Find the recently sold home listings in Siesta Key FL, today! Looking for new homes? Check out the latest Siesta Key homes for sale.

User

CREATE A FREE ACCOUNT

Get INSTANT MLS ACCESS and NEW LISTING ALERTS sent directly to your inbox

Recently Sold Homes in Siesta Key FL

$2,000,000
3 Beds 4 Baths Siesta Key / Sarasota SubDv. 34242 Zip Code
Nestled on a secluded one-acre lot, this coastal-inspired home offers a blend of luxury, privacy, and unobstructed views on the widest part of the peaceful Heron Lagoon. This estate is a true waterfront paradise and was completely renovated in 2019. The home features an open-concept floor plan with architectural details and custom finishes throughout. The living room is filled with natural light through a wall of sliders that access the outdoor pool, spa, and patio. The kitchen is incredible, with ample cabinetry, a custom-designed island with a granite countertop, stainless steel appliances, and is conveniently located between the formal dining room and living room. The adjoining breakfast nook offers stunning views and features a two-story quarried stone wall and large custom windows. The second floor is home to the spacious primary bedroom suite, which includes a 30-foot custom built-in window box, two sitting areas, and a luxurious bath with a soaking tub, dual pedestal sinks, and a walk-in closet. The office and gym can easily be converted into two additional bedrooms if desired. Outside, the property features an expansive waterfront pool and spa surrounded by a paver pool deck, a covered poolside area for watching sunsets or dining al fresco, and large front, side, and rear yards. The backyard also offers access to the water, perfect for fishing, kayaking, paddleboarding, and swimming. Additional features of this exceptional property include a circular driveway with mature pine trees, a second-floor balcony with Trex composite decking, and a lower level with storage, a separate entrance, and a garage that can accommodate four cars. Extensive renovations completed in 2019 include a 50-year tile roof, PGT custom hurricane-impact windows and doors, four state-of-the-art Lenox HVAC units, and much more. The property is also zoned for a second home/guest house, and a dock was previously permitted. With its prime location on Siesta Key, this estate offers the perfect blend of luxury living and waterfront paradise. Just a short walk from your front door, you will find your private marina and the sands of Turtle Beach, while the world-famous Siesta Key Beach and Siesta Village are just a short distance away.

8424 Midnight Pass Road, Siesta Key

$1,550,000
2 Beds 2 Baths Gulf & Bay Club SubDv. 34242 Zip Code
Sunny days and stunning sunsets will be yours to cherish from this 6th floor lookout in building A above the award-winning grounds and lush landscaping of the exclusive Gulf & Bay Club. Step across the threshold into a world where sophisticated style and high-end finishes are accented with whimsical warmth. Glance around the kitchen at the driftwood inspired tile floor setting the perfect foundation for updated white cabinets, gleaming granite counters, a brilliant backsplash surrounding the unique glossy black vent hood, the distinctive beveled mirror glass pantry doors, and the show stopping designer appliances that will make cooking your coastal cuisine a chef’s dream. A sunny corner off the kitchen offers an equally attractive office alcove to keep your busy calendar well-coordinated. Continue past the convenient counter height seating, past the dining nook with additional storage and seating for 4, into the comfortable living area toward the main attraction…the breathtaking view of the Gulf of Mexico. The stunning views continue in the principal suite, the perfect place to relax and indulge in luxury materials and elegant finishes. Hosting is effortless with a second suite, affording your family and close friends a charming, private respite between days filled with Siesta Key adventures. Peace of mind is built in with hurricane rated windows throughout the dwelling while enhanced features such as automatic blinds in the northwest facing windows and double ultraviolet bulbs in the air conditioner for air purification provide essential comfort. This modern dwelling offers conveniences like newly constructed covered assigned parking, a fully renovated in-unit laundry center, and the opportunity to rent monthly. The highly coveted, gated & guarded Gulf & Bay Club boasts 800 feet of water frontage along the white sands of the world-renowned Crescent Beach. This vibrant community offers six tennis courts, three heated swimming pools, a fitness center, dry saunas, a hot tub, electric vehicle charging stations, two clubhouses and an engaging community calendar. Whether you seek beach combing, saltwater adventures, inviting eateries or a vibrant arts & cultural scene you will find what you are looking for on Siesta Key, Florida’s premier vacation destination!

5790 Midnight Pass Road Unit 608, Sarasota

$805,000
3 Beds 2 Baths Palm Bay Club SubDv. 34242 Zip Code
Situated on the ground floor, walk out level of the highly coveted Palm Bay Club on Siesta Key, this ultra rare three bedroom, two bath island respite is now awaiting its next owner. Imagine sipping your morning coffee while you savor the saltwater breeze just steps from the pool and custom spa that overlook the serene intracoastal waterway. One of only 6 units with such a sizable footprint, this space offers a clean, fresh aesthetic and cozy space to relax and recharge between days filled with sandy, Siesta adventures. An open concept space, the kitchen features bright white cabinets, smart stainless appliances and attractive granite counters as well as an open sightline past the convenient counter-height seating into the spacious living area. Just around the corner is a generous dining space with seating for 6. Flexibility abounds as you can host more of your family and friends with the accommodating three bedroom floorplan. Just off the dining room and tucked behind double pocket doors is the first of three bedrooms with a queen bed and sliding glass doors to the patio. The second bedroom, currently used as the primary suite, features a king bed and an en-suite bath. The largest of the three bedrooms houses two full beds while also offering sliders to the patio and private access to the second en-suite bath. As a beach to bay community on Siesta Key, the Palm Bay Club provides admirable amenities to it’s owners from the shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico to the waters of the intracoastal. Enjoy private beach access to Crescent Beach, two heated swimming pools, a fitness center, lighted tennis courts with pickleball, boat docks (for daily rental with a max of 21-ft), BBQ grills, a fishing pier, and new washers and dryers throughout the complex. For the owner/investor, take advantage of the top notch on site rental staff and amazing 3-day minimum rental policy that allows for incredible income potential. Don’t miss this opportunity to own a unique 3 bedroom condo in this highly sought after resort community on Siesta Key, Florida’s desirable vacation destination!

5961 Midnight Pass Road Unit 303, Sarasota

$589,000
2 Beds 2 Baths Vista Hermosa SubDv. 34242 Zip Code
HUGE PRICE DROP! FULLY FURNISHED! Experience the epitome of absolute paradise with this beautiful turnkey, fully furnished and equipped 2BR/2BA villa just a 4 minute walk across the street to the famous siesta key beach. It features a private attached garage and a spacious storage room. Conveniently located right in front of the pool and only a short walk to the beach, you can enjoy all the amenities this villa has to offer. Step inside and be greeted by the stunning porcelain tile flooring that gives a modern travertine look. The tastefully furnished living room and dining room feature 5 inch floor moldings. There are flat screen TVs in the living room and both bedrooms. The kitchen countertop is quartz, complemented by charming tile backsplashes. You will also find quartz breakfast bar seating. Under cabinet lighting is provided in the kitchen, along with stainless steel Samsung appliances and a stainless steel Frigidaire refrigerator. Solid wood cabinets feature soft-close drawers. The villa is equipped with three fans throughout. The master bedroom offers a king-size bed with a custom headboard and furniture on each side. It also has a spacious walk-in closet and a beautiful master bath. The second bedroom features a queen-size bed and a single bed. Just three blocks south is Siesta Key Village, where you can enjoy the Tiki bar, a wide selection of restaurants and plenty of stores and businesses. Don't miss the opportunity to take the free trolley to the north side of town. Come relax and enjoy the beautiful sugar sand found at Crescent Beach on Siesta Key, voted #1 beach in the country!

113 Vista Hermosa Circle Unit 3-A, Sarasota

$715,000
2 Beds 2 Baths Horizons West SubDv. 34242 Zip Code
Private Intracoastal Park. Private and Deeded Siesta Key Beach Access. FULLY FURNISHED with NEW IMPACT WINDOWS. This hidden gem is on a pavered street with beautiful canopied live oak trees. A quick stroll to the waterfront park finds a day dock, intracoastal seating, two waterside grills and plenty of dolphin and manatee viewings. Or cross the street to the crystal sands of Crescent Beach with beach private entrance, 300 feet of deeded beach access, beach cabanas and plenty of beach chairs. Spend the day at the beachside pool and spa, frolic in the gulf waters, or have a cookout at one of the beachside grills. All this and more comes with your 2-bedroom / 2-bath stand-alone villa on one of the prettiest streets on Siesta Key. Move right in or bring your designer to give a modern feel to this island retreat. The large living room feels more expansive with the enclosed lanai that can be used as an office, additional sleeping area, or opened to the living and dining rooms. The villa has generous bedrooms and closet space. The carport can be used as an outside seating and grilling area and contains an enclosed laundry room with plenty of storage for your beach toys, fishing rods and bicycles. Find an additional secluded pool directly across the street from your villa. Horizons West is a Gulf-to-Bay community that offers Weekly Rentals. Condo fee includes roof replacement, all outside maintenance, basic cable, internet, water, sewer, trash, pest, exterior building and flood insurance and healthy reserves. Use the free Siesta Key Trolley to travel the Key to great dining, shopping, and entertainment. Come see all Horizons West and Siesta Key has to offer.

6145 Midnight Pass Road Unit F-1, Sarasota

$975,000
3 Beds 4 Baths Turtle Cove SubDv. 34242 Zip Code
BOATABLE WATERFRONT on SIESTA KEY with NEW dock coming this spring...and seller has ALREADY PAID assessments! This exquisite property, located at the south end of Siesta Key, is nestled is the quiet community of Turtle Cove, which is comprised of only 7 townhome units. With beach access, a public boat ramp and a park only steps away at Turtle Beach, this property offers everything you could want from life on the Key, without the congestion of the more "touristy" areas of the island. And for added convenience, a the Siesta Key Trolley stops just a short walk from your front door, making access to Siesta Key Village and the public beach, not only convenient but fun. In addition to its ideal location, 9000 Midnight Pass Rd provides boatable water access for its residents, with a recently renovated seawall and brand new private docks to be installed this spring. The building also boasts a new roof and a recently painted exterior, adding to curb appeal, and peace of mind. Inside, this large townhome provides ample space, whether you plan to spend part of the year enjoying sunny Siesta Key or are a full time resident. The first floor offers an oversized 2 car garage and a large living area, with hurricane impact sliding glass doors that lead out to the back deck, the community pool, and a peaceful bayou where you will often see manatee and dolphins playing. The main living area is found on the second floor and features a large kitchen with an island, a dining room and living room with a wet bar. From the screened in balcony on the main level, you can enjoy water and beach views. The third level holds all three bedrooms and two full bathrooms, including the oversized primary en suite with vaulted ceilings, three large walk-in closets and a private screened in balcony where you can enjoy views of the sun setting in the Gulf of Mexico. With a two-car garage, the convenience of maintenance free living, access to boatable water and beaches and its peaceful location, this Siesta Key townhome offers a unique combination of features that you won't find in any other property on the market. Schedule your showing today to view this magnificent home.

9000 Midnight Pass Road Unit 7, Sarasota

$14,500,000
6 Beds 8 Baths Sanderling Club SubDv. 34242 Zip Code
Imagine your very own resort-like estate in the heart of the most sought after community in all of Sarasota!  Sanderling Club is nestled on the south end of the world renown barrier island of Siesta Key.  This ultimate beachfront experience is the true definition of living in paradise.  This property offers the most exquisite home on almost 4.5 acres with over 300 feet of beachfront.  The primary residence with over 8,600 square feet of living space is ideally positioned, capturing the amber skyline and emerald green waterways of the Gulf of Mexico from every angle.  The interior design of this magnificent home is perfect for entertaining with the main living areas and spacious dining room facing the west to enjoy Southwest Florida sunsets every evening.   The custom kitchen features Rutt cabinetry, a large island with plenty of seating, Wolf and Sub-Zero appliances, gorgeous marble countertops accented by brushed gold hardware creating an elegant experience in the heart of the home. The family room creates a warm inviting feeling as soon as you enter the space.  The attention to detail throughout including custom moulding, built in shelving, views of mature tropical foliage, and the sparkling pool create such an incredible ambiance and place to create many fond experiences with family and friends.  The home office, only accessed through a secret hidden door, makes working from home a pleasure.  This property is meticulously well maintained with many recent updates to the main house including: brand new roof installed in 2023, new custom kitchen, beautifully renovated bathrooms, new engineered walnut flooring throughout, elegant marble flooring, custom wood millwork, a butler’s kitchen, LED lighting throughout, newer HVAC systems and ductwork, elevator, exterior patio railings, gated entry, Smart Home Wi-Fi enabled automation, and brand new hurricane impact window and doors installed in 2023.  The private owner's suite is on one level featuring a spa-like bathroom with tranquil water views.  The suite offers a private waterfront terrace and dual custom closets. The two guest suites also offer breathtaking views.  The lower level features another full service kitchen, an additional guest space or gym, two full bathrooms, a steam room, a sauna, an expansive garage, and additional storage room.  The second kitchen is easily accessible to the salt water pool and spa, a lighted tiki hut, outdoor fire pit, tennis courts, and a new paved drive space.  The guest house with over 2,300 square feet of living space was built in 2007 and is a kayaker's dream located on Heron Lagoon with 316 ft of waterfront .  With an open great room plan and high ceilings your guests will feel like they are in a tropical oasis. The guest house has a full kitchen, 2 en-suite, bedrooms, a large screened in terrace, and a large deck leading out to the boat dock.  The dock is ideal for launching your kayak or canoe.  Relax and simply sit on the dock and enjoy the sounds of birds chirping and the sound of palm trees swaying in the wind.  This estate is within the guarded & gated community of Sanderling Club. The community offers amenities such as:  a beach club, tennis and pickleball courts, Paul Rudolph-designed beach cabanas, playground, and dockage on the bay.

8218 Sanderling Road, Sarasota

$6,400,000
4 Beds 3 Baths Bay Island SubDv. 34242 Zip Code
Welcome to one of the most desirable properties on Bay Island, “The Gateway to Siesta Key”. 609 Norsota Way is now on the market for the first time in over 42 years! The location of this exquisite piece of paradise offers one of the most impressive, unobstructive bay views of Downtown Sarasota, The Ringling Bridge, Bird Key, Lido Key, and the breathtaking sunsets Florida’s west coast in known for. Nestled in the highly sought-after north end of Siesta Key, this residence boasts 4 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms, set on a remarkable 25,000+ square foot property. The awe-inspiring bay frontage spans an impressive 330' along two sides, featuring one of the only private boat basins on all of Sarasota Bay. Unleash your artistic vision in this property that serves as a canvas for your creativity. You can choose to craft your own masterpiece home or restore the charming existing structure to its former glory. The property offers endless potential for entertainment and indulgence in resort-style living surrounded by the serenity and splendor of Sarasota Bay, while the private boat basin grants direct access to the pristine waters of the Gulf of Mexico. Picture embarking on leisurely cruises or thrilling water sports adventures, creating enduring memories as you set sail from your private backyard. Poised above the tranquil bay waters, this property provides unparalleled panoramic views of enchanting sunsets, city lights, and the breathtaking beauty of nature. Seize this opportunity to own one of the most remarkable properties in Sarasota, where character converges with potential in an extraordinary setting. Your chance to own this distinctive waterfront haven awaits—call today for a private showing!

609 Norsota Way, Sarasota

$9,250,000
5 Beds 5 Baths Bay Island SubDv. 34242 Zip Code
Welcome to Vivre Le Rêve (Living The Dream), an unparalleled estate located on one of the most coveted streets on Bay Island at the northern tip of Siesta Key. Nestled on the Freeling Drive Peninsula, this property sits on one of Sarasota's most secure and picturesque deep-water basins, just moments away from the Gulf of Mexico, with no fixed bridges obstructing your path to open water. Crafted by the renowned architect Clifford Scholz and constructed by Perrone Construction, this fully customized and enchanting residence embodies the elevated coastal lifestyle you've always envisioned. Meticulously preserved by its original owners, Vivre Le Rêve boasts striking curb appeal, lush landscaping, and an impressive 69 feet of bay frontage. The home showcases impeccable craftsmanship and carefully selected natural materials, seamlessly blending coastal exteriors with modern interiors. With 5 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, and 2 half baths, this residence invites you into a world of comfort and tranquility. Upon entry, the home welcomes you with custom moldings, coffered and trey ceilings, and expansive windows, creating an atmosphere of genuine warmth. The family room, kitchen, and bar area provide abundant spaces for entertaining. The kitchen features custom Campbell cabinetry, Quartz countertops, Sub-Zero appliances, and a Wolf Range. A butler's pantry and food pantry separate the kitchen from the formal dining room. The family room, adorned with a stone wall and gas fireplace, boasts 21' ceilings. On the main level, you'll discover a guest bedroom, an office with custom built-ins, a laundry room, powder room, and a full guest bath. A dedicated theatre room offers an unparalleled cinematic experience with 12 theatre seats, acoustically engineered walls, a Runco projector, and an adjustable screen. Moving to the second floor, the master suite immerses you in luxury, featuring an oversized sitting room with a gas fireplace, hinged mirrors for accessories, barn doors for privacy, and a private terrace with expansive water views. The master ensuite offers a spa-like experience with dual vanities, a soaker tub, walk-in shower, water closet, and an oversized walk-in closet with custom built-ins. Additionally, there are two more bedrooms, guest bathroom, a laundry room with sink and refrigerator, and ample storage on the second floor. The ground floor presents a 2.5 car garage with workshop and wired for a electric charging station. In additional there is an oversized garage suitable for an RV, boat, or additional vehicles. Stepping outdoors, you'll be captivated by the Florida living experience. The main level terrace features an outdoor kitchen, sitting area, and expansive dining area, all equipped with motorized retractable screens and storm shutters. A separate outdoor pool bath, in-ground jacuzzi, and outdoor shower enhance the outdoor amenities. Enjoy a dip in the saltwater pool or refine your golf skills on your personal 3-hole putting green in the backyard, which is astroturfed and equipped with Sonance speakers. The waterfront lifestyle is truly luxurious, with a dock and 69' of concrete seawall, accommodating up to a 60' yacht, a 24,000lb boat lift, and a davits for a 16' boat. Numerous other features make this residence the epitome of Coastal Luxury Living, where you are unquestionably Living The Dream!

799 Freeling Drive, Sarasota

$3,600,000
4 Beds 5 Baths Sara Sands SubDv. 34242 Zip Code
Pre-Construction. To be built. The award-winning team at Allegra Homes invites you to explore 5023 Windward on the Key. Coming soon, you will be greeted by a gorgeous curb appeal with mature designer landscaping and 3 car garage with pavered drive, this beautiful new luxury residence on Siesta Key canal front offers a wonderful island lifestyle. Near world-famous Siesta Key Beach and the Village, this location provides easy access by boat to the Grand Canal and out to the Bay and Gulf beyond. With 4 bedrooms and 4.5 baths, this fascinating waterfront home is stylish and sophisticated both inside and out. Plenty of natural light illuminates the neutral tones of the 3,873 square feet of living space. Highlighted throughout are incredible architectural details, and modern high-end fixtures and finishes. The covered double-door entry leads to a two-story foyer with see-through views all the way to the water’s edge. The great room is accented with dramatic volume ceilings, clerestory windows, fireplace, glass shelves with lighting, and triple sliders opening wide to the outdoor leisure area. The dining room with its built-in buffet, aquarium glass window, and water views is adjacent to the sleek island kitchen with SubZero refrigerator, Wolf 5-burner gas stove and pull-down microwave, Wolf oven, and beverage center with wine cooler. The secluded owner’s wing includes an adjacent den/office and spa-experience bath with freestanding tub, zero threshold shower, water closet, and separate double vanities. Extending the width of the house, the pavered lanai with step-down pool and spa level is accessible by several rooms of the house. Enhanced with a stunning wood ceiling, nearly half of the lanai area is covered for a dining space with a fully equipped outdoor kitchen. The downstairs bonus room is poolside and features a wet bar, pool bath, set of barn doors, and wall of sliders opening up to include additional covered area for entertaining. The upstairs bonus room is perfect as a game room or home theater and comes with a Juliette balcony overlooking the great room below. Additionally, 2 ensuite bedrooms are upstairs and complete this exciting floor plan. Newer seawall and very quiet street. Come and stay awhile to soak in all the many intricate details that make this home so delightful. **Photos are of a previous home. Selections and details may vary**

5023 Windward Avenue, Sarasota

Start Your Search