Siesta Key FL Recently Sold Homes

Siesta Key Recently Sold Homes

Find the recently sold home listings in Siesta Key FL, today! Looking for new homes? Check out the latest Siesta Key homes for sale.

User

CREATE A FREE ACCOUNT

Get INSTANT MLS ACCESS and NEW LISTING ALERTS sent directly to your inbox

Recently Sold Homes in Siesta Key FL

$1,125,000
Point Of Rocks SubDv. 34242 Zip Code
Exceptional investment opportunity in a prime location! Just steps away from the iconic Siesta Key Beach, this property is zoned for residential multi-family use and offers excellent short-term rental potential with a 7-day minimum. Imagine building a brand-new, high-earning duplex to generate steady income all year. County approval is already secured for a new duplex, and the current structure is set up as a duplex house with separate electrical panels and two private lanais. The property sustained significant flood damage from the recent hurricanes, resulting in the removal of all kitchen appliances. It currently requires extensive repairs, or you have the option to start fresh with a complete rebuild. The oversized pool adds fantastic appeal and convenience, complete with a recently installed motor, and the fully fenced backyard offers a private oasis for relaxation. With two generous driveways that fit up to 10 cars, plus a paved backyard perfect for gatherings and entertainment, this property is designed for relaxation. The property is in walking distance from the beach. Siesta Key enjoys a strong vacation rental market as the top-rated beach in the U.S., investment properties are in high demand. Vacationers enjoy the free Siesta Key Breeze Trolley that stops just next door and offers transportation to the Village. This is the most competitively priced multi-family property on the Key—don’t let this incredible opportunity pass by!

1132 Crescent Street, Sarasota

$2,350,000
3 Beds 2 Baths Gulf & Bay Club SubDv. 34242 Zip Code
Discover the ultimate coastal lifestyle in this elegant 3 Bed/2 Bath condo, perfectly situated on the top floor of the beachfront F building at Gulf & Bay Club with breathtaking views of Siesta Key Beach. Spanning over 2000 square feet, this corner unit has been completely renovated and is offered turnkey furnished, ready for immediate enjoyment. Step inside to find sleek porcelain tile floors, recessed ceiling lighting, and an open floor plan that seamlessly blends elegance with functionality. The chef's kitchen is a showstopper, featuring stainless steel appliances, quartz countertops, solid wood cabinets with soft-close doors and drawers, a breakfast bar, a spacious island, and a dry bar with a 2-drawer beverage fridge. The beach facing windows are all impact glass, and there are remote-controlled shades on every window to complement the natural light. The spacious master suite is a private oasis with a spa-like bathroom boasting dual sinks and a stunning blue granite walk-in shower. There is plenty of storage with a linen closet and a walk-in closet with built-ins. Two additional bedrooms provide ample comfort for your guests. Additional highlights include a foyer with a coat closet and a bench seat with additional storage. You will appreciate the convenience of your own laundry room. This exceptional condo offers the perfect combination of luxury, comfort, and unbeatable coastal living. Nestled on 32 lushly landscaped acres, Gulf & Bay Club offers the ultimate resort-style living. With 800 feet of private beach, you’ll enjoy breathtaking views, serene sunsets, and direct access to your own slice of paradise. This vibrant gated complex is designed for relaxation and recreation. Amenities include 3 sparkling swimming pools, a rejuvenating indoor hot tub, several dry saunas, pickleball, tennis, basketball, racquetball, and shuffleboard courts. There are two clubhouses, a well-appointed fitness center, multiple BBQ areas, Electric Vehicle charging stations, and a car wash area. A guest suite, available exclusively for owners can be reserved for visiting family and friends. Just a short stroll or free shuttle ride to the Siesta Key Village restaurants and shops or a short drive to downtown Sarasota, this community combines tranquil coastal living with easy access to urban conveniences. Whether you’re relaxing on the beach or staying active on the courts, Gulf & Bay Club truly has something for everyone. It is more than just a home—it’s a lifestyle.

5740 Midnight Pass Road Unit 506F, Sarasota

$5,900,000
3 Beds 4 Baths Seagrove SubDv. 34242 Zip Code
Welcome to Seagrove – the quintessential setting to enjoy maintenance-free, beachfront living on Siesta Key. A rare opportunity awaits you as these residences hardly ever come on the market. This gated, private seaside retreat offers the simplicity and refined charm of traditional beach living with the sophistication of a luxurious home. The Seagrove Beach House is a mid-rise building with only 8 exclusive residences. The Penthouse North is the premier residence in the building featuring unobstructed views to the west and north of the beautiful white sand beach and Gulf of Mexico. Enjoy the peace of mind that comes in a building built strong, with hurricane resistant laminated windows. The spacious interior has over 3000 sf of air-conditioned living space with an open floor plan, Gulf views from all main living areas and an open, gourmet kitchen with top-of-the-line appliances. An intimate breakfast room off of the kitchen is the perfect place to enjoy your morning coffee or tea. The large wrap around terrace features see-through glass railings, an outdoor kitchen with gas grill and plenty of room for lounging or al-fresco dining. Penthouse North has its own, approximately 5000sf, rooftop garden with spectacular 360° views, fire pit, outdoor kitchen, putting green and lounge chairs. You must see this to believe it. There is nothing like it on Siesta Key! The community amenities include a grand swimming pool, hot tub, summer kitchen, fire pit, grill & your own private poolside cabana with refrigerator & custom cabinetry. The secure, gated beach access ensures exclusive entrance from the shores of the Gulf. In addition, Seagrove has a full-time, on-site, building concierge who is available to assist with any and all of your needs, including towel service, receiving packages, attending to your residence or even detailing your car! The refined-coastal architecture of Seagrove draws its inspiration from traditional locales such as Savannah, Charleston and the romantic islands of the West Indies. This is the ultimate haven to enjoy intimate relaxation and luxurious elegance. Additional features include secure keyless entry with private elevator lobby, closed-circuit security, private over-sized, air-conditioned 2-car garage with additional storage. Conveniently located close to the south bridge to Siesta Key, accessing the mainland is a breeze. There are dozens of restaurants nearby on the island or across the bridge. Come discover the best of beachfront living on Siesta Key. An opportunity like this does not come around very often.

1000 Seagrove Lane Unit PHN, Sarasota

$685,000
2 Beds 2 Baths Siesta Rev SubDv. 34242 Zip Code
Charming Coastal Cottage on Siesta Key – Steps from a Hidden Gem Beach. Nestled in the heart of Siesta Key, this delightful 2-bedroom, 1.5-bathroom cottage is the epitome of island living. Located just a short stroll away from one of Siesta Key’s best-kept secret beaches, this home is the perfect retreat for those seeking tranquility with easy access to pristine sands and turquoise waters. Sitting on an expansive 10,000+ square-foot lot, this property offers ample space and privacy with room to expand, garden, or create your own tropical oasis. The home’s classic terrazzo flooring stretches throughout, creating a cool, stylish, and durable surface that reflects the cottage’s unique charm and mid-century roots. While the property has been impacted by recent storms, cleanup is underway, and with a little TLC, this cottage has the potential to shine as a cozy island haven. OR BUILD NEW. With its prime location, inviting atmosphere, and authentic character, this home provides an incredible opportunity for those looking to invest in one of Florida’s most desirable coastal communities. Embrace the island lifestyle, bask in the Florida sunshine, and create lasting memories in this charming Siesta Key gem. Key Features: Two spacious bedrooms and 1.5 bathrooms. Terrazzo floors throughout for easy maintenance and coastal style. Impact Windows. Large, private 10,000+ square-foot lot with room for expansion or a lush garden. Short walk to a secluded beach, Ongoing cleanup and repair work post-storm – a rare opportunity to customize and restore.

141 Garden Lane, Sarasota

$1,475,000
3 Beds 2 Baths Midnight Harbor Sub SubDv. 34242 Zip Code
This is a stunning waterfront retreat with endless potential. Nestled in a tranquil and highly desirable location, this charming waterfront residence offers an unlimited opportunity to be part of the Florida lifestyle. Situated on an expansive lot along a scenic wide canal, this home is just three properties away from the open Bay, to ensure breathtaking views and immediately access to boating, sailing, fishing, and all your favorite water activities. This home features 3 bedrooms and 2 baths with functional layout that invites personalization. Whether you choose to make enhancements to the existing structure or undertake a complete rebuild to suit your unique tastes, the possibilities are endless. The outdoor space is equally impressive, with a private courtyard that boasts a sparkling pool and a soothing jacuzzi—perfect for relaxing in the sun or cooling off on warm days. For boating enthusiasts, the property is equipped with a boat lift, while the spacious Tiki hut offers a wonderful space for entertaining or simply unwinding in the shade. Enjoy the cool breeze and watch stunning sunsets over the canal, all from your own backyard. This oversized lot offers an extraordinary opportunity to create your dream home or preserve the current residence as your ultimate waterfront getaway. With a prime location just minutes from the open Bay, this is a rare chance to own your own slice of paradise. Don’t miss out.

1231 Starboard Lane, Sarasota

$1,300,000
4 Beds 3 Baths Siestas Bayside SubDv. 34242 Zip Code
LOCATED ON SIESTA KEY . . . PROXIMITY TO BEACH . . . 2017 NEW ROOF . . . 2021 NEW HOT WATER HEATER . . . 2018 NEW POOL SCREEN . . . 2016 REPLUMBED . . . REFACED KITCHEN CABINETS . . . OVER 1/3 OF AN ACRE LOT . . . LOCATION . . . LOCATION . . . LOCATION . . . Imagine daily walks on the famous powdery sands of Siesta Key and enjoying the breathtaking sunsets over the Gulf of Mexico daily. This property is situated on a quiet dead-end street, close to Heron Lagoon and Roberts Bay with lush landscaping on an oversized lot. This 4 bedroom, 2.5 bathroom home is spread across 2,512 square feet and offers you the opportunity to live the coastal Siesta Key lifestyle. The home sits on a .38-acre lot providing ample outdoor space for relaxation and entertainment. The property also includes a pool, perfect for enjoying the Florida sunshine. The interior is a comfortable layout with a generous living area, split floor plan with 2 guest rooms on one side with a full size bathroom and the primary space on the opposite. The large primary bedroom has two closets, one walk-in and one reach-in. There is another bedroom and half bath toward the front of the home which could also serve as an office. The flooring is a mix of true hardwood floors and tile. The front door opens up to a welcoming view of the pool, outdoor space, conversation room and a formal dining area. The kitchen is expansive with an abundance of storage and cabinet space. Located in a very desirable neighborhood, this is the perfect home for anyone looking to enjoy the Sarasota and Siesta Key lifestyle. Call today for your private tour.

737 Tropical Circle, Sarasota

$950,000
4 Beds 3 Baths Siesta Cove Sub SubDv. 34242 Zip Code
No Flooding or Water Intrusion during recent storms (per Sellers) – this Island home located moments away from renowned Siesta Key Beach. Situated only a half mile from white sandy beaches of Siesta Key this island gem in SIESTA COVE beckons with its idyllic surroundings. The residence waiting for your finishing touches features 4 bedrooms, 3 full bathrooms, 2-car attached garage and a NEW ROOF in July of 2023. Nestled on a generous lot spanning 0.43 acres with a large tropical yard and stone paver driveway, creating a welcoming entrance to a private oasis. Enter through double doors framed with glass panels on either side, greeted by a large foyer, up a few steps to a spacious open Great Room floorplan. The airy living space (above BFE) features a wood-burning fireplace and a large wall of sliding glass doors that open out onto the expansive covered deck and screen enclosed in-ground pool. Surrounded by lush vegetation, the pool area provides a sense of tranquility and privacy, an inviting space for unwinding after a day at the beach. A thoughtful layout with vinyl plank flooring throughout most of the interior. The large dining room seamlessly opens to the kitchen. Two bedrooms, each with its own en-suite bathroom and sliding doors leading out to the covered deck, offer multiple primary bedroom options. Two additional bedrooms located behind a sliding barn door share a full bathroom, ensuring ample space and privacy. The private tropical backyard retreat with lush Florida landscaping offers low-maintenance yet a visually pleasing backdrop for outdoor enjoyment. This desirable neighborhood is just a short distance from boutique shopping and restaurants of Siesta Village. Over the north bridge, just 15 minutes to Downtown Sarasota’s urban and cultural amenities, shopping, dining and entertainment. Whether as a permanent residence or a vacation retreat, create your own haven in this sought-after paradise where you’ll embrace the laid-back coastal lifestyle of Siesta Key.

5309 Siesta Court, Sarasota

$458,000
2 Beds 2 Baths Anchorage SubDv. 34242 Zip Code
One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged. UNBELIEVEABLE OPPORTUNITY to Seize the Moment for the Savy Buyer to Purchase this 2 Bedroom, 2 Bath Condo and Turn it Into the Beach Beauty of Your Dreams! Rarely Does an OPPORTUNITY Come Along to Renovate and Update a Property Like this at Such a Low, Low Price. Located in The Anchorage, a Well-Maintained Building which was Re-plumbed in 2020, and has Completed the Milestone Structural Inspection in 2022, The Anchorage Offers DEED RESTRICTED BEACH ACCESS to the Gulf of Mexico RIGHT ACROSS THE STREET. The Entrance/Lobby has been COMPLETELY RENOVATED (2024) with BRAND NEW TILE FLOORS. Featuring 2 Spacious Bedrooms, 2 Baths, and 2 Walk-In Closets PLUS an IN-CONDO LAUNDRY ROOM Accommodating a FULL-SIZE Washer & Dryer, NEWER CARPET and INTERIOR PAINT (August 2023), this 2nd Floor Unit has a PEACEFUL TREE-LINED VIEW FROM its Balcony (6ft X 34 ft) with Southern Exposure, and a Water View of the Canal and Docks to Enjoy Sunrise and Colorful Sunsets on Siesta Key. ALL ROOMS HAVE SLIDING GLASS DOORS LEADING TO THE BALCONY. The ON-SITE RENTAL OFFICE Opens Up a World of Possibilities to RENT YOUR CONDO When You Aren’t Using It, or INVESTORS Will Have the OPPORTUNITY to RENT the Unit WEEKLY, 52 Weeks a Year! The Amenity-Rich Anchorage Offers Owners and Renters a Gated Entrance, An OLYMPIC-SIZE HEATED POOL, Fitness Room, Lighted Pickel Ball & Tennis Courts, Clubhouse, BBQ & Picnic Areas, His & Hers Saunas, Kayak Storage, and FREE DOCKAGE for Your Boat Along the Seawall. Relax in an Adirondack Chair Along the Intercoastal Waterway as the Sail and Power Boats Pass by. Within Walking Distance is the Daiquiri Deck, Captain Curt’s Crab & Oyster Bar, and Clayton’s, Plus a Variety of other Popular Restaurants & Shops along with the Siesta Key Marina. Take the FREE TROLLY to Siesta Key Village to Enjoy More Shopping, Entertainment and Dining Options. Located Adjacent to the Stickney Point Bridge, You’ll Have Easy Access to the Mainland and Beyond. Bring Your Creative Ideas and Fulfill Your Siesta Key Beach Dreams. IRRESISTABLY PRICED, This Condo is the Deal You’ve Been Waiting For!

6415 Midnight Pass Road Unit 206, Sarasota

$2,700,000
3 Beds 4 Baths Siesta Beach SubDv. 34242 Zip Code
Come live the good life on Siesta Key in this spectacular Grand Canal- front home with water views, boat dock, bay access & gorgeous salt pool with travertine decking & custom summer kitchen. Casual elegance is exuded in every room of this 3 BR, 3.5 BA home, from the 1200 sq. ft. sprawling European style open kitchen to the full wall of glass sliders opening to the expansive outdoor living space. The main level of this 2019 custom home boasts an oversized entry foyer, a light and bright open kitchen flowing into the living area, sliders to the open pool with cable wire railing and built-in summer kitchen. The second level of the home features an extraordinary primary suite with an outdoor sitting area and covered balcony with views of the pool and Grand Canal. Enjoy a large soaking tub and spacious shower in the primary bath and an expansive primary closet. Two additional en suite guest bedrooms and a laundry room round out the second floor living areas. NO HOA Fees is an added plus! Highlights of this home include hurricane impact windows/doors, elevator with three stops- garage, main and top levels, Tesla charging station, automated custom European window treatments, central vacuum system, and new 10,000 lb. boat lift and dock (built to fit a 27' boat), oversized two car garage, balconies at front and back of the home, etc. Just minutes from the intracoastal waterway, Gulf of Mexico, and Siesta Key village! Siesta Key is proud to provide the best coastal lifestyle possible - island living, breath-taking sunsets, boating and award winning beaches are at your doorstep!

4866 Commonwealth Drive, Sarasota

$10,350,000
5 Beds 8 Baths Cocoanut Bayou SubDv. 34242 Zip Code
A True Island Estate…This picture perfect home is located in The Exclusive Cocoanut Bayou neighborhood. An intimate community with estate sized parcels, deep water docks, canopy lined streets and even a gated private beach. This home was redesigned by Clifford Schultz and could be featured in House Beautiful. The gated parcel is almost 2/3 of an acre, complete with mature tropical landscaping. The home features an oversized Chicago brick motor court with a 3 car side entry garage. The custom wood detailing throughout includes mahogany entry doors, crown moldings, cased impact windows, shiplap ceilings, wainscoting, custom built-ins and more. A gourmet kitchen with Campbell Custom Cabinetry featuring a butler’s pantry, a beverage station, Wolf appliances and an entertaining island complete with additional seating. The main house has a foyer gallery wall, soaring ceilings, picture perfect views, a Holiday sized living room, a coveted great room, a morning room, a private office, as well as a spectacular Owner’s suite…. all located on the first living level. The owner’s suite has a large sitting area, a spa inspired bathroom and 2 walk-in closets. The second floor has a hobby room, 3 ensuites and a flex room. The guest house above the garage has a kitchenette, a great room and an ensuite with private entrance in close proximity to the main home. The outdoor veranda is complete with kitchen, dining and living areas. The mesmerizing views of the Bayou are ever changing, a kaleidoscope of nature … you will see dolphin, manatee, area fish and seabirds, mangroves and much more. A resort style pool with travertine pavers, a separate spa, a large garden, and 2 boat docks complete this waterfront lifestyle. Cocoanut Bayou is minutes to Siesta village for shopping, dining and Siesta’s world-famous beach. You are close to downtown Sarasota which is known for its cultural significance. The opera, orchestra, ballet, symphony, performing arts center, art galleries are all at your disposal. Shop, dine or just enjoy the city that embraces it all. Sarasota County really has something for everyone. Selby Botanical Gardens, Mote Marine Aquarium, several nature parks, bike trails, water sports, Polo, sport venues, multiple Universities and the list goes on. Don’t wait to discover this unique opportunity … It will not last long.

241 Cedar Park Circle, Sarasota

$2,023,000
3 Beds 4 Baths Bay Island SubDv. 34242 Zip Code
PRICE IMPROVEMENT! Step through the grand, gated entrance of 548 Siesta Drive and be greeted by a luxurious waterfront estate on Florida's breathtaking Siesta Key. This 4399 square foot waterfront haven exudes elegance from the very curb. As you pass through the wrought iron gate the home stands proudly on this .38 acre property amidst lush tropical landscaping and a custom brick paver driveway that can accommodate multiple cars. Step inside through the solid double doors to the dazzling grand foyer with gleaming porcelain tile floors sets the stage, plantation shutters filtering in warm sunlight. Coffered ceilings soar overhead, adorned with elegant chandeliers and recessed lighting that bathes the space in a warm glow. Fourteen-foot-high ceilings are further emphasized by grand columns that line the entryway and flow into the formal dining area. The back wall of the living area is a masterpiece of light and openness. Andersen sliding glass doors stretch from end to end, revealing a breathtaking vista of the pool, entertainment space, and the shimmering waterway beyond. Imagine hosting unforgettable gatherings for your family and friends. Providing ample space guests, the home features three comfortable bedrooms, each with a luxurious touch and feel. An additional loft space offers versatility, perfect for a home office, media room, or extra sleeping quarters. The 3.5 bathrooms are tastefully designed with beautiful bright cabinetry, lighting and gold fixtures. The heart of the home is a bright kitchen, boasting ample storage in stylish Shaker-style cabinetry. A center island with granite countertop and vegetable sink provides the perfect spot for meal prep, while expansive windows ensure every seat at the breakfast table enjoys the stunning lanai, pool and water views. The luxurious feel extends to the private quarters. Large bedrooms offer spacious en suite baths, custom closets, high ceilings adorned with crown molding, and morning porch for relaxing creating a sense of spacious comfort. The elegant primary bathroom is a spa-like retreat, featuring multiple vanities, a dedicated makeup vanity, gold fixtures, soaking tub with separate shower, water closet, and gleaming porcelain tile flooring. The garage/man cave is a luxury car owners dream featuring marble floors, cabinetry, air conditioning and flat screen television. But the true star of the show unfolds behind the house. Imagine a sparkling oasis – a gorgeous open pool surrounded by swaying palm trees, a paver deck and a privacy wall, creating a secluded haven for relaxation. The 108 linear foot water frontage includes a double-dock with two boat lifts. The canal ends in a cul-de-sac at this point so you can enjoy access to the Gulf but not a lot of boat traffic behind your home. 7 Day Min Rental! This isn't just a house; it's a luxurious waterfront sanctuary designed for grand living and unforgettable memories. From the tropical landscaping and inviting pool to the expansive living areas and opulent bathrooms, this home promises an unparalleled Siesta Key experience. Siesta Key itself is a paradise, renowned for its sugar-whit sand beach, consistently rated among the nation's finest. Beyond the beach, Siesta Village pulsates with energy, offering a delightful mix of shops, restaurants, and nightlife. Immerse yourself in the natural beauty of the area's parks or explore the hidden coves accessible by kayak or boat. Siesta Key truly delivers an idyllic Florida lifestyle.

548 Siesta Drive, Sarasota

Start Your Search