Siesta Key FL Recently Sold Homes

Siesta Key Recently Sold Homes

Find the recently sold home listings in Siesta Key FL, today! Looking for new homes? Check out the latest Siesta Key homes for sale.

User

CREATE A FREE ACCOUNT

Get INSTANT MLS ACCESS and NEW LISTING ALERTS sent directly to your inbox

Recently Sold Homes in Siesta Key FL

$1,650,000
4 Beds 4 Baths Siesta Rev SubDv. 34242 Zip Code
Welcome to The Morrison House, a stunning waterfront retreat that blends modern luxury with a touch of historic charm. Nestled along a deep-water canal just minutes from the Gulf of Mexico, this 4-bedroom, 3 ½ bath, 2,812 SF home offers a rare opportunity to embrace the ultimate Sarasota lifestyle. Originally built in 1996 and extensively updated through 2014, the primary residence is a showcase of current design, featuring soaring ceilings, expansive open spaces, and every modern convenience. Complementing this is the adjoined 1940s-era original cottage, a beautifully renovated gem that adds historic charm, making this property truly one of a kind. As you step inside, the grandeur of the modern home takes center stage. The open floor plan flows effortlessly from room to room, with abundant natural light streaming through oversized windows. The chef’s kitchen is a true showstopper, featuring premium two-toned cabinetry, sleek stone countertops, a custom range hood, and top-of-the-line appliances, including a wall-mounted oven and sleek cooktop. Adjacent to the kitchen, the spacious great room is perfect for gatherings, with large sliding doors opening onto the outdoor patio, seamlessly blending indoor and outdoor living. The luxurious primary suite is a private sanctuary designed for relaxation. Boasting an elegant, spa-inspired bath with chic finishes and a soaking tub, this space exudes tranquility. A private study adds versatility and makes this suite a perfect retreat. The expansive outdoor living area features a sparkling pool and spa, surrounded by landscaping that ensures privacy and serenity. A private dock, complete with boat lift, provides deep-water access just a few lots away from the pass and Gulf of Mexico beyond. While the modern home shines, the property’s historic portion, known as The Morrison House, adds a unique layer of character. This charming 1940s cottage has been carefully preserved and integrated into the property, offering a cozy space perfect as a guesthouse or extension of your living area. With its heart pine floors, original cedar paneling, and vintage fireplace, it’s a delightful nod to Sarasota’s rich history. The local historic designation also brings significant advantages, including relaxed building codes, exemption from FEMA’s 50/50 rule, and tax incentives for further renovations—allowing you to personalize the property to your exact vision without compromising its integrity. In 2024, the home demonstrated remarkable resilience, weathering a hurricane and tropical storms with minimal impact. While some flooding occurred, immediate professional remediation was completed, and repairs are underway to restore the property to pristine condition. With quotes finalized, you have two exciting options: purchase now as-is at an incredible price and personalize the finishing touches, or wait for permitting and renovations to be completed and secure the home at a future higher price. With a seller-provided 2-year home warranty for peace of mind, this property is an incredible opportunity to own a resilient and beautifully updated coastal retreat. Use it as a spacious primary residence, scalable for your lifestyle, or make it your dream vacation retreat, located minutes from the powdery sands of Siesta Key Beach and vibrant Siesta Key Village. With a low 7-day minimum rental policy, it’s also perfect for the charming bed-and-breakfast you’ve always dreamed of owning. Schedule your private showing today.

115 Edmondson Avenue, Sarasota

$850,000
2 Beds 2 Baths Whispering Sands SubDv. 34242 Zip Code
One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged. Fantastic price reduction on this miracle condo! No storm damage! What a wonderful opportunity for someone to own a ground floor condo steps to a private beach only for Whispering Sands owners and their guests, and the beautiful sparkling blue Gulf waters. This 2 bedroom/2 bath condo has been lovingly cared for by the same family for 27 years. They were pleasantly surprised that the condo did not have any water or sand inside after the storms, but only some water on the lanai. There are tile floors throughout. No popcorn ceilings. Both bathrooms have been updated with quartz counters and new cabinets with soft closing drawers. The kitchen has Corian counters, a mixture of newer and older appliances, and a built-in desk area. The exterior Hurricane rated sliding glass doors have been removed because of the concrete restoration project which is ongoing. There are hurricane shutters for the interior sliding glass doors. The exterior sliders will be re-installed in April of 2025. A 26 ft Lanai runs along the beachside with sliders off the living area and primary bedroom. The condo is very livable as it's now, but if a new owner wanted to open up and remodel the kitchen, this would be the perfect time to do it. The condo comes with a carport, and an additional storage closet close by for storing beach items. Whispering Sands has two heated pools, a Tower Lounge and Clubhouse, fitness center, grills, canoe/kayak storage racks. It is within walking or biking distance to Siesta Village, where you will find shops, restaurants, Morton's Market. Downtown Sarasota is about a 15-minute drive, and you can enjoy even more restaurants, shops, the Opera House, Florida Studio Theater, and McCurdy's Comedy Club. This condo is directly on the beach, waiting for a new owner to make memories and to enjoy Gulf breezes and sunsets like this family has for years.

19 Whispering Sands Drive Unit 103, Sarasota

$1,275,000
2 Beds 2 Baths Sarasota Surf & Racquet SubDv. 34242 Zip Code
Just in time for the lucrative winter and spring season on Siesta Key, this stunning two bed, two bath beach condo presents an enticing opportunity to own at the incomparable Sarasota Surf & Racquet while earning income. Located in the highly sought after building Y, this spacious retreat blends coastal living and modern comfort. Located just steps from the sandy shore, life is (literally) a breeze with attractive and durable LVP flooring throughout. Inside, the open floor plan creates a bright and airy space. The kitchen is adorned with whimsy and features bright white cabinets and appliances topped with neutral stone countertops that gleam under the updated recessed lighting and crown molding detail. Whether you are cooking for two or a few, you can serve your creative cuisine at the convenient counter seating, or the dining space equipped for four. Plush furnishings create a snug sanctuary to kick up your feet and recharge. The show stopping moment is on the enclosed lanai, where the pub table and four chairs provide a perch to drink in the view swaying palms and warm waves lapping on the white sand. Neutral and calming, the owner’s suite is a peaceful retreat with an updated bath and ample storage. Host family and friends in the comfortable and generous guest quarters with an additional full bath. Sarasota Surf & Racquet offers the best of the Florida lifestyle on 13 acres of beachfront property with amenities that include two large, heated swimming pools; three tennis courts and two pickleball courts; a well-equipped fitness center; beachside and poolside barbecue grills. A top notch onsite rental service is available for your convenience!

5924 Midnight Pass Road Unit 209, Sarasota

$1,087,000
2 Beds 2 Baths Siesta Breakers SubDv. 34242 Zip Code
Stop Dreaming—Start Living Your Siesta Key Beachfront Reality! Now is the time to bring those offers and make your dream of owning beachfront property on Siesta Key a reality. This coastal haven at Siesta Breakers offers not only a luxurious retreat but also a turnkey investment opportunity with reserved bookings already in place. A Coastal Luxury Retreat: This newly updated 2-bedroom, 2-bathroom condo immerses you in beachside elegance, featuring: High-impact hurricane windows in every room for security and storm protection. Remote patio shutters, offering peace of mind and convenience. A new wall of mirrors in the living room, perfectly positioned to reflect the breathtaking beach views, creating a sense of endless space and natural beauty. An Island Oasis Steps from America’s #1 Beach: Situated in the Siesta Breakers luxury condominium resort, this property is mere steps from the world-renowned sands of Siesta Key Beach. A short stroll along the property’s private path brings you directly to the Gulf of Mexico for daily beachside relaxation. Thoughtful Design & Functionality: Inside, the home boasts a serene coastal ambiance, meticulously designed for comfort and style. A dedicated office nook off the kitchen provides a peaceful workspace with ocean views, making it easy to blend work and leisure. Turnkey Investment Potential: With flexible one-week rental policies permitted 52 times a year and on-site management, this condo is the perfect combination of personal enjoyment and investment opportunity. Exceptional Community Amenities: Two lighted tennis courts for active fun. A refreshing swimming pool to cool off on warm days. Assigned covered parking for added convenience. Prime Location at the Heart of Siesta Key: Just a short walk from the vibrant South Village, you’ll find an array of dining, shopping, and the lively Siesta Key nightlife. Your Slice of Paradise Awaits: With its prime location, automatic hurricane shutters, and thoughtfully curated design, this condo offers the ultimate in beachside living. Whether you’re searching for a permanent residence or a lucrative investment, this gem at Siesta Breakers is your chance to experience the best of Siesta Key. Don’t miss out—Dreams really DO come true!!

6480 Midnight Pass Road Unit 506, Sarasota

$780,000
3 Beds 2 Baths Siesta Beach SubDv. 34242 Zip Code
*FEMA APPRAISAL STRUCTURE VALUE IS $446,000* Presenting a unique restoration or new build opportunity in the heart of coveted Siesta Key. This home sits on an expansive 10,000+ square foot lot just moments from Siesta Key's world-renowned white quartz sand beaches. While the property has sustained some damage from recent storms, it offers solid bones and incredible potential for those looking to restore or build new. The existing home features three spacious bedrooms, two bathrooms, new 2024 roof, and updated plumbing throughout and to the curb. Whether you choose to renovate this gem or start fresh, you'll be perfectly positioned to live the ultimate Siesta Key lifestyle. Located on lovely "Sandy Beach Avenue" and surrounded by many high end, new construction properties, this property offers a serene escape while being just a short stroll to the pristine beaches and azure waters of the Gulf of Mexico, Siesta Key Village dining, shopping and vibrant entertainment. This property presents an exceptional opportunity for either a full-time residence or vacation retreat in one of Florida's most desirable coastal communities. For investors, the location is ideal for travelers eager to discover the area's pristine beaches and abundance of recreation. With its prime location, generous lot size, and endless potential, this property offers the chance to create your own slice of paradise in the heart of sunny Siesta Key!

5133 Sandy Beach Avenue, Sarasota

$390,000
1 Beds 1 Baths Contntls Sea Club SubDv. 34242 Zip Code
SUPERB DAILY VACATION RENTAL on the world-famous SIESTA KEY known for sugar sand beaches, fine dining, excellent shopping, tons of nightlife and entertainment in Siesta Key Village. Cobalt blue waters are just across the street with a gated and deeded access to the sand where you can spend your day swimming, sunning and building castles on this perfect island on the gorgeous Gulf of Mexico. SEA CLUB II is unique in that it allows daily rentals and is right on the Intercoastal Waterway and walking distance to the beach. All unit owners can self-manage or choose their own rental agent. This is a very busy and successful vacation rental, and a buyer is welcome to continue with the services and the rentals that are on the books. Turnkey furnished and ready for your guests this one bedroom, one bathroom is decorated in a coastal style and has everything needed to go to the beach and have fun! Walk out the door and jump on the free trolley and head down to the Village to grab drinks and dinner or go shopping at one of the many wonderful local shops. From parasailing to boating, or paddle boarding be as active as you like or just grab a book and head out back to the lawn overlooking the ICW and read and relax under a big shade tree. The onsite pool is newer and truly resort like with spectacular water views and a tiki hut and bar for dining and party sized grills if you want to dine poolside. The fishing pier is also newer and a great place to relax and catch your dinner. The boat basin was just updated and is wonderful to use for boating or kayaking. The Adirondack chairs on the lawn by the ICW are very comfortable and are a good spot to sit and watch the dolphins and sea birds and manatees. Bocce Ball court is nearby the pool. A clubhouse room with a kitchen and tv, bathroom, mail room all have more living spaces to enjoy. The pool bathroom has showers and changing area to help accommodate guests who may be checking out but still need to be on site. A community laundry room is conveniently located. The extra outdoor storage area is spacious and gives you even more room to keep extra items. The monthly condo fee covers water, sewer, trash, basic cable and all of the amenities located at SEA CLUB II. If you have always been wanting a place on SIESTA KEY this is a great value in that you can have a vacation home that pays for itself and has a strong rental history. Magical SUNSETS every night and volleyball at the public beach and even a drum circle on Sunday evening! Living in PARADISE! NO DAMAGE FROM HURRICANES! Solid construction

5955 Midnight Pass Road Unit 12E, Sarasota

$623,000
2 Beds 2 Baths Our House At The Bch SubDv. 34242 Zip Code
Reduced! The Best Price for a 2 Bed with a Garage on the Key! Your place at the beach needs to be Our House at The Beach. This 2 bed 2 bath 2nd floor unit with it's own 1 car garage is beautifully updated with carefree bamboo floors in all the living space and ceramic tile in the baths, oversize crown moldings and base trim. It offers lake views with a fountain and a twenty-foot-wide balcony overlooking the lake to enjoy your morning coffee or evening cocktails. Sliders bring in plenty of light and you face west to enjoy the evening light from Siesta’s famous sunsets. Your unit offers an extra deep garage to keep both your vehicle and all your beach toys. If it is raining you drive in and you are undercover all the way to your unit. The kitchen has newer black appliances and granite counters – when you rent, they show less handprints etc. And because Our House has a great onsite rental program and very flexible scheduling you get the added bonus of owning a strong rental that you can enjoy yourself as well. Ready for the Beach? Directly across the street is the public beach that Dr Beach ranks in the top 10 in the US year in and year out – just can’t beat that crystal sand. Staying active is easy too with onsite resort pool and tennis courts. This unit had no storm damage – the garage received some water and it was completely and professionally restored. The entire complex will be retrofitted with impact glass and sliders and the seller has paid or is paying the assessment completely by closing. As a second-floor unit you can rest easy about any future storms and you get higher ceilings and nobody walking over your head. At just $500 a square foot this represents one of the best values on the Key for a 2 bed. Easy to show during January so schedule it today!

1137 Lake House Circle Unit C215, Sarasota

$2,275,000
2 Beds 2 Baths Revised Plat Of Siesta SubDv. 34242 Zip Code
For the first time in 70 years, “Blue Bayou” at 3210 Higel Avenue has come to market. This is a once in a lifetime opportunity to own part of the most desirable northern end of Siesta Key. This is a unique property at a unique time. Blue Bayou is currently the only buildable lot available with bay views, no-bridges-to-bay sailboat water, on a protected bayou with a seawall and boat slip, ready for your own custom dock. North Siesta Key is arguably one of the best neighborhoods in Florida, private, quiet and peaceful, with friendly neighbors, and where each local street is a non-through street. Enjoy fishing, boating, kayaking, and paddleboarding from your backyard. Just a short distance away is your own sandbar full of amazing wildlife for snorkeling, fishing, exploring, swimming, or just relaxing. Also explore Sharker’s Island sandbar, and Lido beach, both within close proximity to your own private oasis. From your windows, lawn, patio, rooftop deck, or infinity pool you might relax in the evening seeing roseate spoonbills in golden sunsets on the bay, as well as the glistening lights of downtown Sarasota. At night, the quiet waves with birdcalls and the city lights in the distance reflect off the calm bay waters. Great egrets, snowy egrets, night herons, great blue herons, black skimmers, owls, and both brown and white pelicans are often seen or heard from this, your new home. This unique property is ready for development - survey, zoning and environmental documentation is available upon request.

3210 Higel Avenue, Sarasota

$8,100,000
4 Beds 7 Baths Siesta Rev SubDv. 34242 Zip Code
Nestled within the coveted north end of Siesta Key, this extraordinary residence boasts a blend of modern & contemporary elegance. Situated on an expansive lot spanning approximately 0.45 acres along the scenic Roberts Point Rd, the home welcomes you through private gates into your own secluded sanctuary. Possessing a spacious driveway with garages accommodating up to 7 vehicles (5-car garage with 2 car lifts), the magnificence of this home is evident from the moment you arrive. Embellished with lavish landscaping & showcasing a grand entrance featuring a striking 6-foot by 12-foot pivotal door, this home sets a tone of unparalleled luxury. Step inside to discover a blend of state-of-the-art technology and top-of-the-line kitchen appliances catering to the discerning chef & family alike. Enjoy breathtaking views of Nettie Bayou, providing access to exceptional boating waters and direct routes to Sarasota Bay and the Gulf of Mexico. Conveniently located near renowned beaches such as Siesta Key Beach, Lido Beach & the Venice jetty - this luxurious residence ensures easy access to waterfront bliss. Designed by DSDG (Mark Sultana) Architects, the open-concept layout on the main floor seamlessly integrates the kitchen, dining area, family room, movie room, butler's pantry, additional pantry with a refrigerator, office, & half bath. Expansive sliders extend the living space to an outdoor oasis featuring a kitchen, fire pit, & dining area with electric roll-down screened enclosures & a pool bath for ultimate comfort. The stunning pool/spa area, enhanced with fire bowls offering a perfect retreat for relaxation & entertainment. Ascending to the mid-level you will discover a private guest room with an en suite & a private office/yoga room. Continue to the upper floor, where the sprawling primary suite awaits, featuring his & her spacious walk-in closets, a coffee bar, and a luxurious master bathroom with a water room. Spectacular water views & a large private balcony enhance the allure of the primary suite, while the second & third bedrooms on this level offer equally stunning views, spacious accommodations, en suite and privacy. Convenience is key with a laundry room located on the upper floor, equipped with all the amenities for storage & washing. An additional bonus area/gym on the garage level offers panoramic views of the car lifts and vehicles, enclosed with glass & featuring a half bath & mini split a/c unit. The home is equipped with an elevator & a 60k Generac generator with a 1,000 gallon propane tank to run the entire home down to landscape lightning through any power outage with ease & comfort. The home is adorned with exquisite lighting fixtures throughout, with a beautifully designed wine area greeting you upon entry. Additional enclosures ensure privacy & security for the side & backyard areas. A 16,000lb boat lift with a dock adds to the beauty, inviting you to bring your boat & explore the waters at your leisure. Enjoy leisurely walks through the serene neighborhood, with minimal traffic and panoramic water views. Shell Beach, just a short distance across Higel Ave, offers a peaceful escape with its pristine pure white sand & lovely sunsets. Experience the charm of the village with its exceptional restaurants, shops, & the renowned Siesta Key Beach, easily accessible by golf cart, bicycle, or car. We eagerly await the opportunity to introduce you to this extraordinary home & help you make it your own. Turnkey is an option! Bedroom Closet Type: Walk-in Closet (Primary Bedroom).

3960 Roberts Point Road, Sarasota

$850,000
3 Beds 2 Baths Ocean Beach SubDv. 34242 Zip Code
Beautiful home located in the heart of picturesque Siesta Key. This home offers the perfect blend of island living and untapped potential. While recently impacted by Hurricanes Helene and Milton, this property remains a rare gem with endless possibilities to restore and reimagine your dream coastal retreat. Located just minutes from world-famous Siesta Key Beach, this property is your chance to own a slice of paradise! Step into this serene escape surrounded by mature tropical landscaping, offering privacy and tranquility. A tall rock waterfall flows into the recently resurfaced pool that dazzles with mosaic tiles from top to bottom. The Japanese Teahouse in the pool area is a unique feature that adds a touch of elegance and serenity for enjoying peaceful moments surrounded by nature, perfect for entertaining or unwinding in your personal paradise. Open-concept living and dining areas with plenty of natural light. Large windows overlook a private backyard and mature Live Oak. Circular paver driveway and carport for convenient island living. Opportunity Awaits - hurricane damage remediation was performed after Helene by Servpro, but not after Milton’s lower water level, creating a unique opportunity for a buyer with vision to restore or reimagine this property. With its solid structure and unbeatable location, it’s the perfect canvas for creating your dream coastal retreat. Renowned for its sugar-white sand beaches, turquoise waters, and laid-back vibe, Siesta Key offers a vibrant community and easy access to Sarasota’s cultural attractions. Whether you’re an investor or looking to create your forever home, this property is ready for a new chapter. Don’t miss this rare opportunity to bring your vision to life! Siesta Key living starts here! Home is sold as-is.

4431 Ocean Boulevard, Sarasota

Start Your Search