Sarasota FL Homes for Sale Under $500,000

Homes for Sale Under $500,000 In Sarasota FL

Browse current home for sale under $500,000 in Sarasota FL. Can't find a home that fits your needs? Try our Advanced MLS search. You can easily filter properties by location, price, amenities, and more to find exactly what you're looking for.

User

CREATE A FREE ACCOUNT

Get INSTANT MLS ACCESS and NEW LISTING ALERTS sent directly to your inbox

Homes for Sale Under $500,000 in Sarasota FL

$450,000
2 Beds 2 Baths Phillippi Landings SubDv. 34231 Zip Code
Price Adjustment! An exceptional value for the view, location, and lifestyle—this sixth-floor, two-bedroom, two-bath residence is a rare opportunity that should not be overlooked. From the moment you enter, expansive water views command your attention, setting the tone for this open and inviting floor plan where water surrounds you in every direction. The spacious, light-filled kitchen offers abundant storage and serves as a natural gathering place for guests. Just beyond, you’ll find a convenient laundry closet, a full guest bath, and a generously sized second bedroom—ideal for visitors or a home office. The main living area easily accommodates both comfortable seating and a formal dining arrangement, flowing seamlessly into the great room and out to the oversized screened balcony. This elevated vantage point is perfect for relaxing, entertaining, and taking in sweeping waterfront views that are increasingly hard to find at this price point. The owner’s suite is thoughtfully positioned for privacy and features direct access to the lanai, allowing you to wake up to tranquil water views each morning. Two walk-in closets and a spacious en-suite bath with both a soaking tub and separate shower complete this retreat. This unit has a deeded parking space under cover in the garage. There is also a storage unit assigned to this unit for seasonal accents. Set within a beautifully maintained 10-acre waterfront community, residents enjoy resort-style amenities including a heated pool and spa, fitness center, clubhouse, and an expansive promenade along the water—ideal for sunset strolls. There is a Kayak launch access and private storage racks offer direct connection to Phillippi Creek for boating and nature lovers. The location further elevates the value: minutes from The Landings Shopping Center, Southside Village, downtown Sarasota, UTC Mall, and the white-sand beaches that define Florida’s Gulf Coast. When combined with the views, amenities, and low-maintenance lifestyle, this residence represents an outstanding opportunity—offering coastal living at a price that is increasingly rare for this setting.

1921 Monte Carlo Drive Unit 603, Sarasota

$450,000
Orange One SubDv. 34236 Zip Code
Pre-Construction. To be built. Introducing Orange One! Downtown Sarasota and the Rosemary District’s newest and brightest shining star, Orange One is a 30-unit mixed-use development in the red-hot Rosemary District. Ten three-story condominium residences, alongside 10 retail condominium spaces. Plus, another 10 three-story townhouses meander along 4th St. Why lease when you can own your own retail unit for under $400,000? These spacious, 799-square-foot retail spaces are lining the sidewalks of North Orange Ave. Three different floor plans are available. These are "gray boxes," meaning you get to finish them to your specific needs at your expense. Developers supply floor, wall, and ceiling systems, electric panels, fire sprinklers, and alarm systems, and we also rough in half-baths in each unit. Of course, all exterior glass and door systems are complete and maintained by HOA. Come take advantage and see why the Rosemary district is the place for your retail enterprise. Great traffic is to be expected in a great downtown location. Take a look around the location to see 65 restaurants within five blocks, as well as art galleries, theaters, farmers market, John Ringling Bridge, and Lido Beach all close by. Downtown shopping, culinary delights, and the Sarasota art scene are all at your doorstep. Just a few minutes away is Sarasota Bay and the new 50-acre Bay Sarasota Park, a game changer for everyone who lives, works, and plays in Sarasota. Call today for your private showing.

410 N Orange Avenue Unit 118, Sarasota

$449,977
3 Beds 2 Baths Gulf Gate SubDv. 34231 Zip Code
Virtually Staged. From the moment you arrive, you will immediately notice the combination of an oversized driveway, garage, and covered carport. With room for multiple vehicles, guests, a boat, or weekend toys, this is the type of flexibility you hope for. That's not a stone roof either.... It's an ALL NEW Decra metal roof which gives the home a clean, updated look while adding long-term value and protection. Located at 5929 Murdock Ave, this Sarasota home has been fully renovated with the updates that matter most. Inside, you’ll find new vinyl flooring throughout, fresh paint, updated bathrooms, and hurricane-impact sliders that bring in natural light while adding peace of mind during storm season. The major systems have already been addressed as well, including all new electrical and plumbing that has been professionally scoped, giving the next owner confidence in what they’re walking into. Every update was made with everyday living in mind — creating a home that feels fresh, functional, and ready to enjoy from day one. More than just cosmetic improvements, this is a home where the work has already been done, allowing its next owner to simply move in and make it their own in Sarasota. Updates: 2019 Permit - Mechanical change out - HVAC System - new heat pump - rear unit, 2021 All new LVP flooring throughout the main house, 2021 Installed fence around back yard, 2022 New dishwasher, 2023 Permit - Re-Roof - Decra stone coated metal roof Installed by RoofTech Roofing & Waterproofing, Inc, 2023 New garbage disposal, 2023 Septic tank pumped with full inspection & maintenance, 2023 Installed all new water valves throughout the house, Bathrooms, kitchen & laundry room, 2024 Permit - Rewiring the entire house, new electrical panel, outlets, switches & all new fixtures. Also installed a whole house surge protector at the panel, 2024 Installed new tankless water heater, 2024 Installed new door between the garage and kitchen to meet FBC (was glass door before), 2024 New upgraded stainless steel kitchen sink, 2024-25 Re-screened rear porch, 2025 Full master bathroom remodel, 2026 Full hall bathroom remodel, 2026 Interior Paint, 2026 Exterior paint, 2026 Installed new impact glass sliding doors in living room & master bedroom.

5929 Murdock Avenue, Sarasota

$449,900
4 Beds 2 Baths Paddocks Central SubDv. 34240 Zip Code
Welcome home to this fantastic property nestled in a quiet community. As you arrive, you'll immediately appreciate the oversized two-car garage and the gorgeous, tree-filled lot offering plenty of shade, privacy, and exceptional curb appeal. Inside, this inviting 4 bedroom, 2 bathroom home features comfortable living spaces designed for both everyday living and effortless entertaining. High ceilings, abundant natural light, and tasteful tile and laminate flooring throughout create a bright and welcoming atmosphere. At the heart of the home, the well-appointed kitchen offers matching appliances, a cozy breakfast bar, and ample cabinetry to accommodate all your culinary needs. The spacious primary suite serves as the perfect retreat, complete with a beautifully updated en-suite bathroom featuring a relaxing walk-in shower and a generous walk-in closet. Three additional bedrooms provide plenty of space for family and guests or can easily be adapted into a home office, hobby room, or fitness area. Step outside to the charming screened-in patio, the ideal spot to enjoy your morning coffee, unwind with a glass of wine, or gather with family and friends for an al fresco meal. Beyond the patio, the expansive fenced backyard is shaded by mature trees, including fruit trees, creating a secluded oasis with endless possibilities for gardening, entertaining, recreation, or simply relaxing. Located in the peaceful community of Paddocks Central, this home also offers the added benefits of low HOA dues and minimal restrictions, giving you the flexibility to truly make it your own. Combining comfort, charm, and convenience, this exceptional property is ready to welcome its next owners. Whether you're searching for your first home or your forever home, this is one you won't want to miss. Schedule your private showing today before it is gone!

2405 Icecapade Drive, Sarasota

$449,900
4 Beds 2 Baths North Vamo Sub 2 SubDv. 34231 Zip Code
Two homes, one savvy investment—this full duplex hands you double the opportunity beneath a single roof. Each side offers two bedrooms and a bathroom, along with a range, refrigerator, and the everyday luxury of an in-unit washer and dryer. Across a combined sixteen hundred ninety-four square feet, there's room enough to house tenants on both sides or live in one while the other quietly pays your way. Here's where imagination earns its keep. This property practically begs for a thoughtful refresh—modern finishes, updated fixtures, a splash of style—and the upside for anyone willing to roll up their sleeves is genuinely exciting. Whether you rent both units for steady dual income or reserve one as your own, the numbers have a pleasant way of adding up. Location does plenty of heavy lifting too. Sprouts Farmers Market sits practically next door, turning weekly grocery runs into a two-minute errand. Wharf Road Park offers a nearby patch of green for morning outings or lazy weekend afternoons, and a convenient bus stop along the Tamiami Trail keeps you connected to the wider area. Downtown Sarasota, sandy shores, and an ever-growing lineup of shops and eateries all stay comfortably within reach. Rarely does a property balance solid rental potential with such an inviting canvas for improvement. For investors chasing cash flow or dreamers ready to build sweat equity, this one checks the right boxes. New Septic being installed. Curious what a little vision could unlock? Schedule your showing today.

1805 Marbeth Street Unit 1805/1807, Sarasota

$449,900
4 Beds 2 Baths North Vamo Sub 2 SubDv. 34231 Zip Code
Attention income seekers: here's a full duplex where two complete homes share one smart investment, each offering two bedrooms, one bath, and a floor plan ready to put money to work. With 1,694 square feet spread across both sides, this property practically hands you a built-in revenue stream from the moment you turn the key. The math is refreshingly straightforward. Two rentable units mean two monthly checks, giving you the flexibility to lease both for maximum yield or live in one while the other quietly covers your costs. Each home comes equipped with a range, refrigerator, and its own washer and dryer—amenities that keep tenants happy and turnover low. Better still, the property carries genuine renovation upside; a few thoughtful updates could lift rents and boost your return in short order. Location does plenty of the heavy lifting when it comes to attracting quality renters. Sprouts Farmers Market sits practically next door for effortless grocery runs, while Wharf Road Park offers green space for weekend leisure just around the corner. A nearby bus stop along Tamiami Trail keeps tenants well connected, and the surrounding Sarasota neighborhood adds steady demand that landlords love. Whether you're building a rental portfolio, seeking a house-hack that pays your mortgage, or simply chasing dependable cash flow, this duplex delivers the fundamentals plus room to grow. Opportunities that combine location, layout, and upside like this move quickly. Schedule your private showing today and start counting the returns. New Septic System being installed.

1805 Marbeth Street Unit 1805/1807, Sarasota

$449,900
2 Beds 1 Baths Ringling Park SubDv. 34234 Zip Code
STEP BACK IN TIME and experience the charm of "OLD FLORIDA" in this beautifully preserved bungalow located west of North Tamiami Trail in the highly sought after Ringling Park neighborhood. Situated on a spacious lot with a large fenced backyard, private driveway, and covered carport, this 2-bedroom home showcases timeless architectural details, including gleaming terrazzo floors, graceful arched openings, and elegant plaster cove ceilings that capture the character of the 1950s. The thoughtfully updated interior features a beautifully remodeled kitchen with new cabinetry, quartz countertops, modern lighting, and newer appliances, along with an updated bathroom, All 19 windows have been replaced, an almost-new HVAC system, a 150-amp electrical panel, updated tilt-in windows throughout, restored terrazzo flooring, and luxury vinyl plank flooring in the inviting Florida room. Additional living spaces include a welcoming front porch, rear porch, spacious living room, bright Florida room, and an oversized laundry room. Adding to the home's long-term appeal, the former motel at the corner of 23rd Street and North Tamiami Trail is slated for redevelopment into Artscape Sarasota – One Stop Housing, an innovative mixed-use community designed to provide affordable housing and creative space for artists to live, work, and learn. Offering historic character, modern updates, and an outstanding location just minutes from downtown Sarasota, the Bayfront, dining, shopping, and the arts, this exceptional home is attractively priced at $449,900.

1020 23rd Street, Sarasota

Start Your Search